My first boss in this business, the late Gene Anderson, used to collect briefs filed by insurance companies in cases around the country. Then, when a carrier attempted to take an inconsistent position in a case that he was handling, he would present the court with a brief filed by the carrier somewhere else, in
Gene Killian
The duty of good faith and fair dealing in litigation
Really good stuff over at Chip Merlin’s blog about what happens when insurance companies and trial lawyers mislead courts.
The duty of good faith and fair dealing
I’m just back from Orlando where I had the opportunity to speak at an ABA conference on business interruption insurance. During the talk, I referred to a case I often cite, Rawlings v. Apodaca, 151 Ariz. 149, 726 P.2d 565, 1986 Ariz. LEXIS 253 (1986). For me, the key quote from the case is:
“In…
Other insurance clauses and the duty to defend
New York’s highest court just handed down an interesting decision in Fieldston Property Owners Ass’n v. Hermitage Ins. Co. The case involved an underlying suit for “injurious falsehood,” and the question of who was obligated to provide a defense – the CGL carrier, the D&O carrier, or both? The CGL policy stated that its coverage was…
Contingent Business Interruption Coverage
Here’s a pretty good article from ABC news about how contingent business interruption coverage works. There have been a lot of questions about this coverage folowing the earthquake in Japan.
More on Business Interruption Insurance
In the last post, we took a look at the Dictiomatic case, in which the policyholder took a beating for overreaching on a business interruption claim. Turnabout being fair play, let’s now have a look at a recent case in which the insurance company got thumped in the business interruption arena. The case is Amerigraphics…
Business Interruption Insurance
I’m getting ready to speak at an ABA-TIPS conference on the topic of business interruption insurance. Given the number of horrible tragedies we’ve been through in the past decade (prayers for all those affected by the earthquake in Japan), it’s certainly a timely subject.
To cut to the chase: Business interruption insurance is designed to…
Spider-Man and Event Cancellation Insurance
This weekend, my family is taking me to see “Spider-Man: Turn off the Dark” to celebrate the 12th anniversary of my 39th birthday. (The show is still in interminable previews.) Given how things have gone so far for Spidey, I’m hoping that one of the actors doesn’t land on my head. Anyway, over at…
ERISA’s “arbitrary and capricious” standard
There’s a disturbing article over at Bloomberg about the (pretty horrendous) games insurance companies play with respect to policies governed by ERISA. The ironic thing is that the ERISA statute was designed to protect workers. But the so-called “arbitrary and capricious” standard of review sets such a low bar that claims often get denied for reasons invented…
The statute of limitations for insurance claims
A couple of weeks ago, we got a nice result ($13 million verdict) following a three-month trial in BASF Catalysts, LLC v. Allstate Insurance Company, one of the last great complex environmental coverage beasts. We had the pleasure of co-counseling the matter with Dave Oberdick and his team from the Pittsburgh, PA firm of Meyer…